Mock DraftsMay 29, 2004


Post to Twitter

Mock Auction

By Arlo Vander

There is no such thing as a definitive auction cheat sheet. Even more than serpentine drafts, each auction is unique, and variations between one and another can be enormous. Nonetheless, analyzing mock auctions can be a key to success when it’s time for the real thing, and the strategies used in the Cafe’s very first auction are well worth analyzing. Armed with $200 budgets, this group of drafters used diverse tactics in an attempt to come away from the table with the best roster (see below for league settings), ranging from paying top dollar for elite players to relying heavily on sleepers. The results certainly provide quite a bit of food for thought, both for auction veterans and those looking to try this style for the first time this season.

PlayerPositionPriceTeamDrafter
Priest HolmesRB$60KCPmix
Ladainian TomlinsonRB$56SDArgos
Clinton PortisRB$56WasChaindog35
Ahman GreenRB$56GBKingGhidra
Shaun AlexanderRB$53SeaKingGhidra
Deuce McAllisterRB$52NOCupertino_11
Jamal LewisRB$48BalNittany Lions
Ricky WilliamsRB$47MiaPmix
Edgerrin JamesRB$47IndCupertino_11
Randy MossWR$40MinM_Zimm
Domanick DavisRB$38Hounebbie2004
Marvin HarrisonWR$38IndCupertino_11
Torry HoltWR$37StLM_Zimm
Fred TaylorRB$36JaxUtopianHopes
Marshall FaulkRB$36StLgoleafsgo96
Chad JohnsonWR$35Cingoleafsgo96
Daunte CulpepperQB$35MinM_Zimm
Santana MossWR$34NYJKingGhidra
Hines WardWR$34PitM_Zimm
Terrell OwensWR$33PhiPmix
Peyton ManningQB$32IndUtopianHopes
Tiki BarberRB$29NYGChaindog35
Anquan BoldinWR$29AriUtopianHopes
Kevan BarlowRB$25SFgoleafsgo96
Darrell JacksonWR$25SeaChaindog35
Joe HornWR$25NOnebbie2004
Koren RobinsonWR$25SeaNittany Lions
Stephen DavisRB$24CarNittany Lions
Derrick MasonWR$23TenUtopianHopes
Matt HasselbeckQB$23SeaNittany Lions
Plaxico BurressWR$22PitArgos
Michael VickQB$21AtlArgos
Steve SmithWR$21CarChaindog35
Rudi JohnsonRB$21Cinnebbie2004
Travis HenryRB$21BufArgos
Donovan McNabbQB$20Phigoleafsgo96
Amani ToomerWR$20NYGnebbie2004
Andre JohnsonWR$19Hounebbie2004
Todd HeapTE$19BalArgos
Trent GreenQB$18KCnebbie2004
Tony GonzalezTE$18KCChaindog35
Brett FavreQB$17GBChaindog35
Chad PenningtonQB$17NYJCupertino_11
Steve McNairQB$17TenKingGhidra
Laveranues ColesWR$17WasPmix
Jeremy ShockeyTE$17NYGgoleafsgo96
Isaaac BruceWR$16StLNittany Lions
David BostonWR$15MIAgoleafsgo96
New England PatriotsD$15NEM_Zimm
Eric MouldsWR$14BUFKingGhidra
Alge CrumplerTE$13ATLnebbie2004
Chris ChambersWR$12MIACupertino_11
Marcel ShippRB$12AriUtopianHopes
Corey DillonRB$12NEM_Zimm
Aaron BrooksQB$11NOArgos
Brian WestbrookRB$11PhiNittany Lions
Duce StaleyRB$11PitPmix
Tom BradyQB$10NEUtopianHopes
Mike VanderjagtK$10IndM_Zimm
Lee SuggsRB$9CleArgos
Michael BennettRB$9MinArgos
Jeff WilkinsK$9StLUtopianHopes
Jimmy SmithWR$9JaxUtopianHopes
Peerless PriceWR$8Atlgoleafsgo96
Charles RogersWR$8DetCupertino_11
Javon WalkerWR$8GBArgos
Curtis MartinRB$8NYJChaindog35
Baltimore RavensD$8Balgoleafsgo96
Tampa Bay BucsD$8TBnebbie2004
Chris BrownRB$8TenCupertino_11
Jerry PorterWR$7Oakgoleafsgo96
Keenan McCardellWR$7TBUtopianHopes
Eddie GeorgeRB$7Tennebbie2004
Marc BulgerQB$6StLPmix
Peter WarrickWR$6CinChaindog35
Garrison HearstRB$6DenUtopianHopes
Warrick DunnRB$6AtlChaindog35
Randy McMichaelTE$6MiaNittany Lions
Jeff GarciaQB$5CleNittany Lions
Reggie WayneWR$5IndNittany Lions
Keyshawn JohnsonWR$5DalNittany Lions
Justin McCariensWR$5NYJArgos
TJ DuckettRB$5AtlLgoleafsgo96
Charlie GarnerRB$5TBPmix
Shannon SharpeTE$5DenPmix
Jake PlummerQB$4DenCupertino_11
Rod GardnerWR$4WasArgos
Rod SmithWR$4DenPmix
Marty BookerWR$4ChiChaindog35
Quentin GriffinRB$4DenUtopianHopes
Marcus RobinsonWR$3MinCupertino_11
Ashley LelieWR$3DenCupertino_11
Anthony ThomasRB$3ChiKingGhidra
Onterrio SmithRB$3MinArgos
William GreenRB$3Clenebbie2004
Boo WilliamsTE$3NOM_Zimm
Matt StoverK$3Balnebbie2004
Adam ViniateriK$3NEArgos
Miami DolphinsD$3MiaArgos
David CarrQB$3HouKingGhidra
Byron LeftwichQB$2Jaxgoleafsgo96
Josh ReedWR$2BufNittany Lions
Jerry RiceWR$2OakNittany Lions
Ryan LongwellK$2GBNittany Lions
Bubba FranksTE$2GBKingGhidra
Philadelphia EaglesD$2PhiUtopianHopes
David AkersK$2PhiChaindog35
Jason ElamK$2DenChaindog35
Denver BroncosD$2DenCupertino_11
Donte StallworthWR$2NOArgos
Marcus PollardTE$2IndM_Zimm
Deion BranchWR$2NEKingGhidra
Josh BrownK$2BufPmix
DeShaun FosterRB$2CarM_Zimm
Rex GrossmanQB$1Chinebbie2004
Sebastian JanikowskiK$1Oaknebbie2004
Itula MiliTE$1Seanebbie2004
Ike HilliardWR$1NYGnebbie2004
St. Louis RamsD$1StLNittany Lions
John KasayK$1CarNittany Lions
David TerrellWR$1Chigoleafsgo96
Tennessee TitansD$1TenChaindog35
Brandon LloydWR$1SFChaindog35
Jake DelhommeQB$1CarChaindog35
Freddie JonesTE$1AriChaindog35
Dallas ClarkTE$1IndCupertino_11
Washington RedskinsD$1WasCupertino_11
Daniel GrahamTE$1NEUtopianHopes
Troy HambrickRB$1OakUtopianHopes
Tony HollingsRB$1HouM_Zimm
Moe WilliamsRB$1MinM_Zimm
Joey GallowayWR$1TBM_Zimm
Rich GannonQB$1OakM_Zimm
Tyrone WheatleyRB$1OakM_Zimm
Tai StreetsWR$1SFKingGhidra
Carolina PanthersD$1CarKingGhidra
John HallK$1WasKingGhidra
Antonio BryantWR$1DalKingGhidra
Correll BuckhalterRB$1PhiKingGhidra
Dallas CowboysD$1Dalpmix
Dante StallworthWR$1NOpmix
Brad JohnsonQB$1TBPmix
Kevin FaulkRB$1NEgoleafsgo96
Larry JohnsonRB$1KCpmix

 
Assumed League Settings:

Single-season (no keepers), head-to-head with playoffs in weeks 16 and 17, 16-man rosters with the following starters:

1 QB
2 RB
3 WR
1 TE
1 K
1 Team Defense

along with a seven-man bench (any positions).

Scoring assumed is as follows:

Offense:
1 point per 25 passing yards
1 point per 10 rushing or receiving yards
6 points per passing, rushing, receiving or return touchdown
-2 points per interception or fumble

Kicking:
3 points per field goal up to 39 yards
4 points per field goal between 40 and 49 yards
5 points per field goal over 50 yards
1 point per extra point

Defense:
2 point per sack
1 point per blocked kick or punt
4 points per interception or fumble recovery
6 points per defensive touchdown
1 points per safety
1 point per return touchdown
10 points for a shutout
7 points for allowing up to 6 points
4 points for allowing up to 13 points
1 points for allowing up to 20 points
0 points for allowing up to 27 points
-1 points for allowing up to 34 points
-3 points for allowing over 35 points
 

Special thanks as always to the drafters who made the Cafe’s first ever mock auction happen. Catch up with all the draft participants in the Cafe Forums.

Post to Twitter

Related Cafe Articles

• Other articles by Arlo Vander
2011 Extremely Early Mock Draft by Jason Singer (posted on 03/15/2011 in Rankings)
2011 Cafe Mock Draft: Lockout Style by R.J. White (posted on 07/31/2011 in Rankings)