Ahman Green, Fred Taylor, or Edgerrin?

[senseiosin]

I have the 11th pick in a non sleeper 12 team league. Im gonna go RB, WR or WR, RB with my first two round picks depending on who's available, I know Ill get either Moss, Owens, or Harrison. Im hoping Travis henry will fall to the 11th, doubt it but you never know, but barring that Im going to have to decide between Ahman Green, Edge, or Fred Taylor. Im leaning towards Edge since I had him a couple of years ago when he was healthy and carried me into the playoffs, Taylor is great when healthy and I dont really know much about Ahman green. How do you guys rank them? Also considering I expect the top 8 RB's to be gone by my pick along with Harrison and possibly Vick/McNabb. Any other RB's you would put above these three (minus the top 8 as I mentioned)?

[joester]

I would rank them Ahman, Edge, Lewis, then taylor.............If henry falls definently take him.

[dgroundhog_ffc]

I wouldn't take Vick, I'd consider McNabb/Owens/Harrison as well. Either way, I'd take a RB and one of the guys I listed. If you take Edge, you probably don't want Harrison. I took McNabb and Edge with the 9th and 12th picks.

[FeArMeNtL]

na dont take ahman because he is going to share his touches with davenport. I would take edgerrin of taylor because edgerrin is a pass rushing back. Tho Fred might have a huge year. It is a toss up between from Fred and Edgerrin

[Vikes Rule 88]

go with Ahman Green he will be a great rb this year

[The Dude_ffc]

what are you talking about fearmental-thanks just plain ignorant advise. Ahman will not be sharing carries. Green is a great pick. He will benefit from a soft schedule and good passing game. He will also catch the ball out of the backfield alot

[Confluence]

If I had to pick today, I would say...

Edge
Fragile Freddie
Ahman "Hold on to the F'n football" Green

[Adlaw]

what are you talking about fearmental-thanks just plain ignorant advise. Ahman will not be sharing carries. Green is a great pick. He will benefit from a soft schedule and good passing game. He will also catch the ball out of the backfield alot

I'm with The Dude on this one. Green is consistent, dependable, and will get 18-25 touches a game.

[Hawk022499]

1. Edge
2. Green (possible contiunued problem w/ knee drops him to #2)
3. Taylor (what can I hurt this year?)

[iceman88]

Edge all the way. He is playing in the best offensive system of the three. I think Taylor will have a good year also, but not real sure about Ahman. Depends on if he stays healthy and how the young GB receivers perform, if they can take pressure off Green. But Edge (He's Back)