If this is not a fantasy question, Viniatieri wins it hands down. Remember the, not one clutch but two clutch kicks he made in the snow against the Raiders? If this is about ability, if this is about making them when they count, its Vinny. And I am not a NE fan.
Oiler coach Bum Phillips: When asked by Bob Costas why he takes his wife on all the road trips, Phillips responded, "Because she is too damn ugly to kiss goodbye."