Whose Star is Brighter, Carr or Leftwich?

[550 Dean]

I've been throwing these two around in my head for weeks and can't decide which guy is going to finish with a better record. They both have questionable running backs, one may have an edge on the receivers but the other just find ways to win. It will be a real problem for me to decide whom to pick next year provided everything remains the same from here on out.

What do you guys think? All homers are invited to chime in.

[Azrael]

Houston's young talent seems to be growing together. Carr - Johnson could be the next Manning - Harrison, Culpepper - Moss in the league.

[moochman]

I think Lefty is going to be a great QB. That said, I would target Carr over him. Lefty has a D, Carr doesn't. Carr also has a young studs at WR and RB. Lefty may be the better NFL QB, ala Brady, but Carr is more likely to have to put up bigger numbers.

[portisfan24]

they are pretty close. For the rest of the season, I dtake lefty stats wise though. He has a better running game and I like their system better. that being said, carr is still a pretty bright star.