better 2nd half of season, Vick or A. Brooks?

[I-man]

Who will be more valuable at seasons end?

[no1cowboysfan]

brooksy

[feverfive]

I don't trust either (I do own Brooks), but I'd say Vick based solely on the fact that he still gets to face the putrid Saints defense twice in the second half of the season.....

[Purple_Pride]

i have the same two QB's and have asked myself the same question many a time. i think vick is highly over rated and brooks is highly un motivated right now so i dont expect big finishes for either but ive decided to play brooks for the time being.

[Steve_ffc]

I like Vick over Brooks for the rest of the season

[I-man]

thanks for everyones help.

[joshyboy72]

its a toss up...saints still play carolina twice, atlanta twice, kansas city once

vick is probably a safer bet, though

[Ricky_Christ]

Close call, but I'd go with Vick.

[Bennett4prez]

Aaron Brooks.

If for nothing else, than merely because Ricky_Christ picked Vick.

[Siggyfawn]

Why don't you trust Brooks? He's been solid all year. And last year. 10 TDs 3 picks. 100 rushing yards. I understand you might not trust black QBs, but Brooks has been very consistant.