Rank David Carr for me

[blb2397]

Just curious
just picked him up and was wondering where everyone ranks him
(For the record my league - 25 yards pass / 10 yards rush = 1pt, 6 pt per TD)


Extra sweet if we could all list the top 10

[Azrael]

Late top 10 FANTASY QB around 8 or 9

1. Culpepper
2. Manning
3. McNabb
4. Favre
5. Bulger
6. Plummer (yeah really, for this year anyways)
7. Vick
8. Carr, Leftwich?

[ljthockey]

Woah Woah you picked him up off of waivers? or trade?

If you got him off of waivers thats a hell of a steal.

Id say hes in the top 8

[ljthockey]

Late top 10 FANTASY QB around 8 or 9

1. Culpepper
2. Manning
3. McNabb
4. Favre
5. Bulger
6. Plummer (yeah really, for this year anyways)
7. Vick
8. Carr, Leftwich?

"

You think Vick is better fantasy value then Carr? wow Vick has been so incosistent he just has amazing talent but hasnt put up that good of numbers.

[Azrael]

They are right around the same value. Vick has scored a little more points fantasy wise but is just coming up on his bye week.

[ljthockey]

Vick- 1390 pass yards 6tds 463 rush 1td Fantasy Points= 65
Carr- 1917 pass yards 9tds 135 rush 0td Fantasy Points= 81

That is yahoo standard scoring what this guy asked for and due to interceptions and what not Carr is beating Vick in fantasy points and Carr had one week less than vick

[Azrael]

In my league Vick has scored 123 and Carr has scored 122.

[ljthockey]

Thats wierd whats so much different about the scoring system then?

[USAFDave]

I traded Carr in my 12 person redraft for Ward earlier this season. Carr was my 11th round pick and was my backup to Manning.

[Azrael]

I know we have no negative points and the rushing yards are 1pt per 10 yards rushing. So Vick's rushing stats roughly translate into 52 pts alone.