The All-Bust Team

[garretterik]

How about drafting McCairens in round 7
JJones in Round 8
TMadox in Round 11
Denver D in 12 (Weren't they supposed to be a top Def with Champ? At least more than 3 int through 10 weeks.)

[biju]

Alright, here's the way I see it:

QB: Chad Pennington - some people had him top 5 this year
RB: Quentin Griffin - one good week and it all went down hill
RB: Travis Henry - needs to leave Buffalo
WR: Peerless Price - needs to leave the NFL
WR: Amani Toomer - needs a QB
TE: Itula Mili - The return of Jerramy Stevens killed him
K: Jay Feely - The decline of Vick killed him
D: Kansas City - Where the hell is Dante Hall?

For the record, these I believe are the ones that compared to where they were drafted are the biggest busts. I'm sure someone with too much time on their hands could come up with something based on ADP and standard scoring to find out the biggest "true" busts.

-M

[Cyclone]

The Panthers D takes the cake for me by leaps and bounds. I have Coles and Barlow, and while they are busts for the most part, for where the Panther's D was ranked pre-season to how they actually performed is a complete 180. They have earned a WHOPPING 35 FP's this season, and I can only kick myself for holding on to them as long as I did.

[Cyclone]

The Panthers D has to take the cake for busts this year when it comes to pre-season expectations to actual performance. For being ranked in the top 5 defenses before the season started, to accumulating a WHOPPING 35 FP's for the season in an ultimate bust. I can only kick myself for hanging onto them as long as I did.

[BrutallyHuge]

2nd Team All-Bust
QB: Aaron Brooks
RB: Kevan Barlow
RB: Rudi Johnson
WR: Chad Johnson
WR: Steve Smith
TE: Shockey
K: Mike Vanderjagt
DEF: Carolina Panthers

Honorable mentions: Stephen Davis, Donte Stallworth, Mike Vick, J. Jones, K. Jones, P. Warrick, TJ Duckett, B. Franks, M. Stover, Marshall Faulk, M. Pollard, Tennessee

How can you put Brooks on a bust team? He's a very late drafted QB (probably like the 10th-12th QB off the board. Plus, he's produced a touchdown in 13 of his past 14 games.

No way can you call Brooks a bust. I think he's a value pick at where he was drafted.

[CC]

Stallworth is awful, I had such high hopes.