Dynasty QB?

[Broncmet]

Who would you rather have, Eli Manning or Mike Vick? I know Vick is dangerous, but he's dangerous with his legs, not so much his arm. WIll he develop into a quarterback, not a running back who throws the ball?

I think Eli is riding the hype, but thats my personal opinion.

[SwiperNoSwiping]

I would go with Eli. Both have immense skills.

I think once the Giants build the team around Eli, he is going to be as successful as his brother. At least I would be taking the chance that he would be.

[FlcnFan]

I personally feel that Vick will begin to dominate in the WCO ala Steve Young...and I think NYG has too many o-line questions for Manning...so right now I say Vick has a better upside over the next couple of years