I did the same thing. I have Dillon playing tonight and Droughns played yesterday. Edge on the bench for 34 points.
Kinda ticks me off, but I played the matchups also. I figured Manning would toss the ball all day again, but they actually let Edge do his job and even get the TD. I have Dillon and 91 pts so far, the guy I'm playing against has Blaylock, Pats def, and 52 points. I think I might win.