You've got to project 5-8th pick range for those two. Who would you pick? It's hard to go against McGahee because if you average out his production, he's a top 5 RB. Given a full season, full off season, full preseason to prepare, it's hard to rate him below top 5. To me it's the yardage he's producing, where Henry couldn't. He has some great speed, breakaway ability, and if they address that O line, plus you have Evans who is starting to come on. It might be a little early, but next year their O might be top 10.
All that being said, with heap back, Boller growing, I like lewis as a semi sleeper due to this off year. If he slips to 7th-10th range, I think he's a steal. Mcgahee might be top 5 pick just on hype alone. I just can't bring myself to take McGahee top 5, I think with the top5 pick you need a history of success, not a good 1/2 year from a rookie. I place him ahead of Brown, but in the same 2nd round steal category.