Which QB do you want?

[joshyboy72]

It might not be a bad move for the Lions to go after Kurt Warner. We all know how well he once played in the dome in St. Louis, and he could do well in Detroit's stadium. And he'd fit in well with Detroit's young, explosive offense...they could use a veteran at QB.

[mutantseabass]

IM actually hoping for Warner for a few reasons.....one is to put some pressure on Joey...two is to show Joey how an NFL qb plays the game.....three is if Joey tanks next year we still have Warner. Harrington has never had an establsihed QB showing him the ropes. As far as McMahon get rid of him hes useless.

[no1cowboysfan]

McMahon hasn't been given a proper chance.

[mutantseabass]

McMahon is a poor poor poor mans Vick minus Vicks talent and speed.

[moochman]

McMahon is a poor poor poor mans Vick minus Vicks talent and speed.

Plus he makes Vick look accurate.
McMahon is terrible. He should probably look at trying out at WR or defensive back because he has no future as a QB.

[mutantseabass]

McMahon is a poor poor poor mans Vick minus Vicks talent and speed.

Plus he makes Vick look accurate.
McMahon is terrible. He should probably look at trying out at WR or defensive back because he has no future as a QB.

Finally someone who sees ol Mike for what he is or isnt in this case, which would be an NFL quarterback. He may be a good slot reciever or return man ya never know. I just get so sick of people saying give McMahon a shot, when they may have seen the guy play in preseason. He has no pocket presence, no accuracy, looks to run before looking at his second checkdown. The guy may have been good in college, i cant comment never seen him play but an NFL qb he will never be. I have read alot of your posts throughout the cafe Moochman and i will have to say i respect your opinons and you have had alot of interesting well thought out posts.