Daunte vs. Peyton

[Bennett4prez]

Alright, the #1 and #2 QBs in the league COULD face off in the Superbowl. If they do, who puts up better numbers over the course of the Playoffs?

Manning's opponents: Patriots, Steelers/Jets, Vikings
Culpepper's opponents: Eagles, Falcons/Ram, Colts

Being the biased homer I am, I choose Culpepper. How do the unbiased see it?

[kevinoc81]

I would guess that C-Pepp would probably put up better numbers against the Eagles, and Rams/Falcons than Manning would against the Pats, and the Jets/Steelers, but I think Manning will show that NO offense in the NFL with a defense as poor as the Vikings can keep up with the Colts!

[CC]

Who cares, theres already a million Culpepper vs. threads, I don't think we need another one. Why not do this thread on McNabb or Bulger?

[mtryanks12]

C-Pep would make the better stats. I still think all this vikings stuff should be stopped. There's like 100 threads about c-pep out right now, and it's getting kind of annoying.

[maddog60]

As much as I'd like to favor Culpepper with two soft defenses if they make it, the Colts only have one tough secondary to beat themselves. The deciding factor for me is that I except Manning to light up the banged up NE secondary with trip and quad packages all day long (Troy Brown is not going to be able to cover Stokley). And since Manning is the better QB, I except him to produce better stats throughout that projected three game stretch.

(It's all moot though, since Culpepper is only getting one more game this year )

[joshyboy72]

enough with Culpepper man. there is no QB better than Manning right now.

see this?--->:X do this--->:X

[Steelers Rule]

manning

[moochman]

Who is this Culpepper guy?

[Azrael]

Manning is the best real life QB.

Culpepper is the best fantasy QB.

Culpepper won my league's MVP 390 traditional fantasy points to Manning's 372 points.

[JohnnyUnitas]

That's right. Fantasy-wise, Culpepper is better than Manning. But in real life, I prefer Peyton anytime!