ODotW: Part 7, Top 10 QB's

[MeShawn]

Next year, I really don't think there is any question in anyone's mind (maybe a tad bit) that Manning, McNabb, and Culpepper are the top 3 fantasy QB's. We already discussed McNabb vs C-Pepp after the Moss trade, so that's irrelavent. After those 3, it's a mystery. Who are the next 7 QB's after them?

Here are some names to ponder (in case your to lazy to look them up).

Trent Green, Michael Vick, Marc Bulger, Brett Favre, Matt Hasselbeck, Drew Brees, Kerry Collins, Jake Plummer, Tom Brady, Aaron Brooks, Chad Pennington, Jake Delhomme, Carson Palmer

--------------------------
Personally, here's my top 10.

...Peyton
...McNabb
...Culpepper

1. Trent Green
2. Marc Bulger
3. Michael Vick
4. Drew Brees
5. Matt Hasselbeck
6. Brett Favre
7. Kerry Collins

---------------------

Offseason Discussion of the Week

Part 1: 2nd Tier RB's, RESULTS
Part 2: Fantasy Defenses, RESULTS
Part 3 (courtesy of J2thez): 2nd Tier WR's, RESULTS
Part 4: Randy Moss vs. Terrell Owens
Part 5: Antonio Gates vs. Tony Gonzalez
Part 6: K Jones vs J Jones vs S Jackson vs T Bell, RESULTS

[mtryanks12]

This is my (personal) top ten:

-Manning
-McNabb
-Culpepper
-Marc Bulger
-Trent Green
-Drew Brees
-Michael Vick
-Tom Brady
-Matt Hasselbeck
-Kerry Collins
-Aaron Brooks

I based my picks on 2004 season performance, and the offseason moves of each QB's team.

[Gunslinger]

After Manning, Culpepper, and McNabb I would rank them as:

4. Hasselbeck
5. Bulger
6. Palmer
7. Green
8. Brees
9. Collins
10. Favre

This is just shooting from the hip. I haven't done any analysis, it's just how I came away feeling at the end of last year while considering some of the offseason moves (Collins). I'm much higher on Palmer than most, and I'm down on Collins a bit even though he did acquire Moss as a WR. He's just an INT machine, IMO. Brady, Brooks, Pennington, and Delhomme could all be in that #10 spot - they're all in that 3rd tier with Collins and Favre.

[Atog]

As things look right now...

-Manning
-McNabb
-Cpep/Bulger
-Vick
-Green
-Brady
-Collins
-Brees
-Favre
-Plummer

I'm putting Cpep and Bulger at a tie right now because i see Bulger's value rising while i don't think that Cpep will do nearly as good without Randy

[disgruntledjetsfan]

I see it this way:

4. Green
5. Bulger
6. Favre (still has a cannon, and Driver and Walker)
7. Brees
8. Collins
9. Delhomme
10. Brady/Hasselbeck

[skibrett15]

here it is

1. Bulger
2. Green
3. Delhomme
4. Hasselbeck
5. Favre
6. Collins
7. Brees

[ljthockey]

Gunslinger has some really controversial rankings Hasslebeck the number 4 qb overall???

Anyways Id rank em

1. Manning
2. Mcnabb
3. Bulger
4. C-Pepp
5. Green
6. Brees
7. Favre
8. Brady
9. Vick
10. Collins

[portisfan24]

hmm this is definately subject to change but I am thinging

1. Manning
2. McNabb
3. Culpepper
4. Bulger
5. Green
6. Brees
7. Collins
8. Vick
9. Hasselbeck
10. Brady

[skibrett15]

Wow, me and DJF are the only ones with D-Home. Nice variation in picks, good topic this week.

[Gunslinger]

Gunslinger has some really controversial rankings Hasslebeck the number 4 qb overall???

Yeah, as I mentioned - those rankings were spur of the moment. I really liked the way Hasselbeck finished up the season. Surely Jackson and Robinson can hold onto the ball at some point in their careers. Well, maybe not. Keep in mind that 2 seasons ago he finished (at least in my leagues) as the #4 QB so I don't consider it too outlandish.

I just don't get as excited about Bulger or Green as most of you. Bulger does at least have some weapons. If Green gets a solid WR via free agency or a trade, he would move immediately up to #4.

Also keep in mind that I have Hasselbeck in my dynasty league so it's also a bit of wishful thinking.