ODotW: Part 7, Top 10 QB's

[Canadian Seahawk]

my personal

1-Carson Palmer
2- Matt Hasslebeck
3- Trent Green
4- Jake Plummer
5- Kerry Collins (yeah I said it)
6- Tom Brady
7- Marc Bulger

[TTTBone]

my personal

1-Carson Palmer
2- Matt Hasslebeck
3- Trent Green
4- Jake Plummer
5- Kerry Collins (yeah I said it)
6- Tom Brady
7- Marc Bulger

Wrench thrower!!!

[Santacruzer]

My biggest gripe with Vick is his inconsistency. That is why he will never end up on any of my rosters.

One week he will have 250 yds passing (a great game by Vick standards) 2 TDs, 100 yds rushing for another TD. Followed by an 85 yd passing game 0 TDs, 15 yds rushing, and maybe add a few INTs and fumbles in there too. Ughhh.

[Gunslinger]

my personal

1-Carson Palmer
2- Matt Hasslebeck
3- Trent Green
4- Jake Plummer
5- Kerry Collins (yeah I said it)
6- Tom Brady
7- Marc Bulger

Glad to see I'm not the only one showing Palmer and Hasselbeck a little respect.

[deluxe_247]

i love palmer...but watching almost every seahwaks game last season, i lost a lot of confidence in hass.

[Trainer of Dolphins]

1. Peyton
2. McNabb
3. C-Pepp
4. T. Green
5. Bulger
6. Hass
7. Vick
8. Plummer
9. Collins
10. Brees

[Kensat30]

The upside to Mike Vick is that most leagues weight rushing yards and rushing TD's heavily over passing yards and passing TD's...

If Mike Vick puts up 2600 passing yards, 1000 yards rushing, 15 passing TD's and 5 rushing TD's (all within his reach), he nets out 320 FFP in that season....

Now, a pure passing QB like Warner or Manning has to put up something like 4000 yards and 30 passing TD's to match that same figure....

It's nothing for Vick to have a 200 yard, 2 TD (passing) and 80 yard, 1 TD (rushing) game... Do the math... That's 32 FF points... Peyton Manning has to put up 320 passing yards and 4 TD's to match that number....

THAT is what keeps Vick in the top 10.... And in most people's eyes the top 5....

Except that Vick usually puts up 175/0 with his 80/1...