ODotW: Part 7 RESULTS

[MeShawn]

Well, last week was a HUGE hit and it was a great discussion indeed. I think most people are finished submitting their rankings, so I'll post the results. Almost 30 sets of rankings this week.

...Peyton Manning
...Donovan McNabb
...Daunte Culpepper

---------------
4. Trent Green
5. Marc Bulger
---------------
6. Kerry Collins
---------------
7. Brett Favre
8. Drew Brees
9. Matt Hasselbeck
10. Jake Delhomme
---------------


Also recieving votes (in this order): Michael Vick, Tom Brady, Carson Palmer, Jake Plummer

I drew in approxmate lines where there were big gaps in average rankings.

If a QB did not make the top 10 in a specific person's rankings, they recieved a null vote = "11" to make the rankings legit (same thing used in other ODotW rankings)

A QB was only eligible to make the rankings if they recieved at least 2 votes (even with the null votes). The Joey Harrington bias by LT Blue Colt was a little obvious

------------------------------------

Offseason Discussion of the Week

Part 1: 2nd Tier RB's, RESULTS
Part 2: Fantasy Defenses, RESULTS
Part 3 (courtesy of J2thez): 2nd Tier WR's, RESULTS
Part 4: Randy Moss vs. Terrell Owens
Part 5: Antonio Gates vs. Tony Gonzalez
Part 6: K Jones vs J Jones vs S Jackson vs T Bell, RESULTS
Part 7: Top 10 QB's

[J2thez929]

Nice job MeShaun. The results came out sort of how I expected them. The big thing, at least in my opinion, is Brees in the 8th spot. It seems like most of you guys think he will continue improving from his past season and not become a one-year wonder.

Good stuff

[no1cowboysfan]

Nice rankings...

I still think Collins is too high though.

[PackerAttack84]

Nice rankings...

I still think Collins is too high though.

I agree, he has never proven that he can be a top fantasy quarterback, and until that happens I will have my doubts.

[joshyboy72]

I sort of disagree, Collins is pretty much where he should be. I can't think of anyone after him that deserves to be ranked above him...

Nice rankings MeShawn, the same 10 as I put. Two differences in the order though.

[mtryanks12]

I also think Collins is too high, because even with a new receiver in Randy Moss, he hasn't proven himself with Randy in the backfield. I'm sure it'll help him, but how much??

Then again, this could just be me.

[ljthockey]

Solid Rankings

I dont agree with Collins so high and Brady and Vick not making top 10 but its still solid rankings

[chaindog35]

i like the rankings, but i'd have vick a little higher

[SwiperNoSwiping]

Those are some great rankings and I recognize it took some time and effort to put them together..Thanks!

I may disagree with a couple rankings but nothing all that significant. I would have expected to see Vick around 8ish...And maybe Collins a hair or two lower.

Nice job.

[Canadian Seahawk]

my personal

1-Carson Palmer
2- Matt Hasslebeck
3- Trent Green
4- Jake Plummer
5- Kerry Collins (yeah I said it)
6- Tom Brady
7- Marc Bulger

Wrench thrower!!!

wow boy I know nothing