D. McAllister Vs. F. Taylor

[NYGiants]

If you could acquire either F. Taylor or D. McAllister by trade, who would you choose and why?? Thanks.

[Arlo]

If I had the choice between those two, I'd rather have McAllister. Both have looked very good so far, but Taylor's injury history does remain a concern.

[Slingblade]

go with McAllister without a doubt, taylors to ricky, to bad i have him in two of my leagues

[kashikis]

go with mcallister hands down for 2 reasons

there both doing good but.....

mcallister is playing on a better team and fragile freddie tends not to make it to deep into the season before he gets hurt

[Guttpuppy]

Agreed with above posts and reasons why.

[JayM09]

everyones agreed go with deuce, not injury prone taylor