Portis Vs McGahee

[Smizzy]

WHo is goin to have the better season?

[Free Bagel]

Mcgahee had almost as many rushing TD's in one game last year (4) as Portis had all season (5).

I just don't see the Skins offense improving enough to get Portis into the endzone consistently.

[Smizzy]

So drafting McGahee over portis in my draft at the #9 spot was the right choice?

[Crafty]

You made the right choice by getting into a league where both Portis and McGahee are available at the 9 pick!

[mtryanks12]

How in the world has MacGahee dropped that far?!?!?!

[Smizzy]

1.Peyton Manning QB Colts
2.LaDainian Tomlinson HB Chargers
3.Ahman Green HB Packers
4.Shaun Alexander HB Seahawks
5.Deuce McAllister HB Saints
6.Priest Holmes HB Chiefs
7.Tiki Barber HB Giants
8.Jamal Lewis HB Ravens
9.Willis McGahee HB Bills
10.Corey Dillon HB Patriots
11. Edgerrin James HB Colts
12. Curtis Martin

ROUND 2

1. -Clinton Portis HB Redskins
2. -Rudi Johnson HB Bengals
3. - Dominick Davis HB Texans
4. - Randy moss WR Raiders
5. -Daunte Culpepper QB Vikings

[UNDEFEATED]

1.Peyton Manning QB Colts
2.LaDainian Tomlinson HB Chargers
3.Ahman Green HB Packers
4.Shaun Alexander HB Seahawks
5.Deuce McAllister HB Saints
6.Priest Holmes HB Chiefs
7.Tiki Barber HB Giants
8.Jamal Lewis HB Ravens
9.Willis McGahee HB Bills
10.Corey Dillon HB Patriots
11. Edgerrin James HB Colts
12. ----

Peyton at One is just wrong...unless they give 10 points for TDs
Ahman at 3 is absent minded

Everything else i can live with.

Talk around here states that Mcgahee is a lock for the TOP 5 and a in some cases out to 7, not too often.

I like the Deuce and Tiki selecctions...Albeit i probably would not make those exact picks.

Do you guys score receptions.

[Evolution]

I can agree with that logic UN, but I cannot see Tiki before Dillon. That's just one I cannot see happening, Dillon's more productive in every aspect (on average), and in a better scenario.

On the rebound, the way that league is going, you might get Portis or Dom Davis, which would be insane.

[Keyser_WV]

I can see Tiki before Dillon, Tiki has averaged 586 receiving yards per year over the last 5 years compared to Dillon's 171.

I think Tiki/Dillon are pretty equal in value. I also think both are going to drop farther than they should in most drafts IMO.

[Gunslinger]

Is this a year where we give Tiki too much respect or not enough? I can't keep it straight. I think it goes even/odd like Moulds breakout seasons but I'm not sure...

I'm definitely not used to seeing Tiki in the top 10, but he did have a great season and there's no reason to expect differently this year, I suppose.

Good pickup - McGahee is a solid pick at #9. Evolution is right, if you get Portis or DD on the way back you're solid.