ODotW: Part 8, RESULTS

[MeShawn]

From the other poll, Gonzo won (slightly), so we'll put him #1 and Gates #2 since that's the majority opinion at the cafe, though I tend to disagree

1. Gonzalez
2. Gates
-------------
3. Heap
-------------
4. Crumpler
5. Witten
-------------
6. Shockey
-------------
7. D Clark
8. Winslow
9. McMichael
-------------
10. Wiggins

Close, but not quite top 10: E Johnson, Franks

Green = Tie


I broke the voting up into MANY tiers so you could get a better idea where the big gaps were in the averages.


---------------------------------

Offseason Discussion of the Week

Part 1: 2nd Tier RB's, RESULTS
Part 2: Fantasy Defenses, RESULTS
Part 3 (courtesy of J2thez): 2nd Tier WR's, RESULTS
Part 4: Randy Moss vs. Terrell Owens
Part 5: Antonio Gates vs. Tony Gonzalez
Part 6: K Jones vs J Jones vs S Jackson vs T Bell, RESULTS
Part 7: Top 10 QB's, RESULTS
Part 8: Top TE's

[mtryanks12]

[Kensat30]

I don't understand the love for Heap. Can someone explain it to me? Why is he head and shoulders (2 tiers) above Shockey?

This might be the wrong thread, but obviously a lot of the cafe feels that he is the undisputed #3 TE behind Gonzalez and Gates and I would like to know why exactly you guys feel that way.

[ljthockey]

Solid rankings I love these things

[Nilmerf]

I also don't get why Heap is the undisputed third. Terrible QB, a hot new WR, and coming off an injury. I like Crumpler and Witten just as much because they're number one targets, and had great seasons.

[joshyboy72]

Although I ranked Heap third in mine, no way did I have him as the undisputed third. For me, it was a very tough decision between him and Witten...finally went with Heap, because as long as he can stay healthy and Jamal is back, plus Mason, that offense should be rolling (plus plenty of good field position from that defense) so Heap should see a lot of red zone action. Witten as a very close 4th.

Nice job once again MeShawn.

[UNDEFEATED]

Meshawn,

These ODOTW's are the $hiiieeeeeet!

BTW....How is my team doing in the Bonanza League? Who is in the 'ship. Deluxe and_______

I stopped dating this girl and i was using her Yahoo account to run my Bonanza league. And its not really time for me to start talking to her yet. Kinda sucks that it happened during the playoffs and championships. crying for my team not the girl.

I am sure that she will give me back control of the team later...and might even set the rosters a couple times. But i am thinking about next season.

[deluxe_247]

Although I ranked Heap third in mine, no way did I have him as the undisputed third. For me, it was a very tough decision between him and Witten...finally went with Heap, because as long as he can stay healthy and Jamal is back, plus Mason, that offense should be rolling (plus plenty of good field position from that defense) so Heap should see a lot of red zone action.

very good explanation.

dont forget heap is bollers favorite target. heap is the teams leading WR. shockey is adapting to a new qb..and witten will have a completely new qb. crumpler has ron mexico throwing to him. i think heap will benefit from mason's presence this year. he will take some pressure off..and if anything give the ravens' offense more of a chance to stay on the field.

i dont think he is head and shoulders above those other guys, but i do believe he is where he should be on the chart at #3 (though i think he can even end up #2). he has potential to be a monster if boller starts clicking.

[MeShawn]

Meshawn,

These ODOTW's are the $hiiieeeeeet!

BTW....How is my team doing in the Bonanza League? Who is in the 'ship. Deluxe and_______

I stopped dating this girl and i was using her Yahoo account to run my Bonanza league. And its not really time for me to start talking to her yet. Kinda sucks that it happened during the playoffs and championships. crying for my team not the girl.

I am sure that she will give me back control of the team later...and might even set the rosters a couple times. But i am thinking about next season.

LOL, a little off topic, but I'll answer your question.

Ironhorse and I are in the finals this week. Deluxe was knocked out last week by Ironhorse. After the first few days, I'm losing 4-8. We hope to have you back next season.

Well, that's enough of that little tangent.

[Evolution]

Although I ranked Heap third in mine, no way did I have him as the undisputed third. For me, it was a very tough decision between him and Witten...finally went with Heap, because as long as he can stay healthy and Jamal is back, plus Mason, that offense should be rolling (plus plenty of good field position from that defense) so Heap should see a lot of red zone action. Witten as a very close 4th.

Nice job once again MeShawn.

This was the same for me, although I did have Crumpler 4th I believe. The #3 through #5 TEs are interchangeable for me.