Cafe June Player Rankings: QB's (Part 1 of 5)

[Free Bagel]

I dont dispute the rankings in general, but I noticed every time you had an "na" you just discounted it in your average. You should take the "na" as the lowest ranking plus 1. So if it was out of 30, an "na" should be 31 and included in your avg

Btw, how in the world was Palmer given an na?

Nebbie, I have to agree here....

Let's say for the sake of dicussion that 1 guy ranked Garcia at 5th, and another guy at 11th, and the rest did not rank him, feeling that he is more like 35th....

The way you averaged them he would end up ranking 8th.... Even though the vast majority of your rankers felt he was not any higher than 35th.....

See what they mean?

Or if one guy was Garcia's "man friend" and ranked him #1 overall and nobody else ranked him he would be #1 overall :O.

Doing it like this, ranking a guy 30th, 29th 28th or anywhere around there is actually WORSE for their ranking then ranking them 18380203834th

[davidmarver]

Hey Nebbie, I suggest you present the statistics using code so the spacing between numbers/letters is equal...makes it easier to read.

[davidmarver]

By the way neb...I had Warner at 17, yet it says na under my name. Only discrepency between the rankings I made and the ones you have listed. Just pointing it out. Good work on compiling them, though.

[Evolution]

I'm actually pretty ticked about this whole process, since I was supposed to be a part of it.

What happened to the deadline being June 4th? Why did it magically disappear? I am REALLY BUZY with other stuff that I'm putting together, and I finally clear a late night to get this done and it ends up being posted without me and at least 1 other member knowing the deadline had been moved up.

Honestly, that's a bad deal nebbie, and this is by no means a discredit to those of you who got your rankings in early. Good job you guys, poor leadership nebbie.

[Flockers]

Thanks for putting this together guys.

[UNDEFEATED]

Thanks for putting this together guys.

FLOCKERS IS BACK

Nice to see you again FLOCK.

[Flockers]

Thanks for putting this together guys.

FLOCKERS IS BACK

Nice to see you again FLOCK.

I've been back for a while.

[AsianChexMix]

Nice list. Just wondering, this is June's so will there be updates to it when it gets closer and closer to kick off time?

[hastur]

oh, man, what a cool idea and post! I agree with PLindsey about the averages rankings, but still solid!

[Canadian Seahawk]

how was Carson Palmer left of completly by the one dude???