my top 30 RB's

[loosechange75]

Running Backs
1. Tomlinson
2. Alexander
3. James
4. McGahee
5. Holmes
6. Dillion
7. Davis
8. Lewis
9. McAllister
10. Kevin Jones
11. Barber
12. J. Jones
13. Ahman Green
14. Portis
15. Johnson
16. Jackson (Young Strong power Running back)
17. Martin (Not going to lead the league but can rack up those yards)
18. Westbrook (if No TO number 1 WR for the eagles)
19. Jordan (Raiders Starter)
20. Bell (Denver will get 1000 yards out of him anyway they can)
21. Staley (will get the yards not the TD’s)
22. Brown (Cris is injury prone same with the guy above him)
23. Foster (same as the guy above him)
24. Williams (Rookie)
25. Brown (Rookie Ricky Williams Return)
26. Benson (Rookie)
27. Taylor (Henry might show up but henry aint on the list)
28. Johnson (larry may get Job from Priest)
29. Dunn
30. Bennett


alright start to critisize

[Ed4252]

Dunn---undervalued each and every year..


because of who?


Duckett

[loosechange75]

i just dont like the offense he is in

[jumpman8828]

To high:

McGahee
Dillon
Davis


Too low:

Holmes (number 2/3)
Lewis
McAllister
Dunn
Bennett (below guys that aren't starting?)

No J.J. Arrington? I'd take him over any other rookies RBs.

[footballfreak449]

Only real problem I have is Larry Johnson being on the list....

He is getting no time this year



Dunn is also undervauled a good bit

[loosechange75]

To high:

McGahee
Dillon
Davis


Too low:

Holmes (number 2/3)
Lewis
McAllister
Dunn
Bennett (below guys that aren't starting?)

No J.J. Arrington? I'd take him over any other rookies RBs.

reason for undervaluing ho,mes is that i feel he is an injury risk and that is why i have johnson on the list and i do feel mcGahee is that high and i would rather have him than holmes and davis is one of the best recieving running backs and was amazing at the end of last year

[rcmman]

my top 11:

1-Tomlinson
2-Alexander
3-Holmes
===big gap between the top 3 and the rest
4-James
5-McGahee
=== another gap here
6-McAllister
7-Lewis
===both jones, dillion, and davis are all very equal in my opinion
8-J. Jones
9-Kevin Jones
10-Dillion
11-Davis

[loosechange75]

wait McGahee is in the same class as holmes and so is edge and davis is ahead of both the jones's

[loosechange75]

No J.J. Arrington? I'd take him over any other rookies RBs.

Why do u like him better then benson and the other rookies

[AI8818]

I agree with Jumpman. Arrington is probly the best rookie RB out there now-a-days. Plus, Thomas Jones could force Benson to split carries. This, combined with the Bears horrific offense, makes Benson the least attractive of the top four rookie RBs in 2005 (Arrington, Brown, Williams, Benson).