PLEASE help me rank these QBs...

[9er Fan]

Warner
Hasselbeck
McNair
Holcomb
Brady
Maddox
Collins
Plummer
Ramsey

[WGreen31]

Warner
McNair
Collins (stability)
Hasselbeck
Brady
Plummer (with all that talent he can't do that poorly)
Maddox
Ramsey (great sleeper)
Holcomb

Like these rankings the best so far. Only thing I would change would be moving Holcomb up 2 spots.

[Warpigs]

Thanks for all the feedback. I appreciate it all greatly. Now a little twist to the question... I was just offered McNair for Plummer and Buckhalter. I start Shaun Alexandr and Travis Henry and have Trung as a backup. The question is, will McNair put up enough numbers above and beyond Plummer to warrant losing the extra depth at RB in Buckhalter? I really like McNair, but the guy has to break down sometime, and he doesn't have too many weapons. However, he put up great numbers each week last year. HELP!!!!

[Yianni2112]

I think Buckhalter will be of greater value once the year starts and he is named the stater and gets 2TD's in week one. Hold on to him. Plumer and someone else not Buckhalter.

[VHawk15]

Kurt Warner
Matt Hasselbeck
Tommy Maddox
Steve McNair
Tom Brady
Kerry Collins
Patrick Ramsey

And I actually think Holcomb is better than Ramsey and Plummer. He could very easily make a good starter and excellent back-up by mid-season.