My Top 15 Lists- Please Tell me What you think.

[Smizzy]

Qb's

1.Manning
2.Culpepper
3. McNabb
4.Green
5.Bulger
6.Hasselbeck
7.Favre
8.Collins
9. Vick
10. Delhomme
11.Palmer
12.Brady
13.Brooks
14.Brees
15.Plummer

Rb's

1. Tomlinson
2. Alexander
3. Holmes
4. McGahee
5. James
6. Dillon
7. Lewis
8. McAllister
9. Davis
10. Portis
11. Tiki
12. Rudi Johnson
13. A.Green
14. Kevin Jones
15. Julius Jones

Wr's

1.Moss
2. Owens
3. Harrison
4. Holt
5. C.Johnson
6. J.Walker
7.A.Johnson
8.H.Ward
9.J.Horn
10.R.Wayne
11.DJax
12. A.Boldin
13. M.Clayton
14.L.Coles
15.D.Bennett

Te's

1. Gonzo
2. Gates
3. Witten
4. Shockey
5. Heap
6. Dallas Clark
7. Crumpler
8. McMicheal
9.E.Johnson
10. Lj Smith
11. D.Jolley
12. Jeb Putzier
13.J.Wiggens
14.M.Pollard
15. T.Johnson

[Cornbread Maxwell]

QBs are pretty normal. Id say you have Hass slightly too high.

RBs - McGahee is too high and Deuce slightly too low. Id be careful ranking Green ahead of KJones - especially with the losses to GBs OLine.

WRs - Pretty standard stuff there too - Id say you have Boldin too high, but then again everyone rates him that high. Also - I would give serious consideration to putting Muhammad in your top 15.

TEs - still pretty normal rankings - the only thing I would suggest is bumping Wiggins up 3-5 spots.

Good rankings for the most part.

[Smizzy]

Thanks CM...I respect your opinion.

[davidmarver]

My only beef is with your QB's. Aaron Brooks is too low...he's finished 6th, 6th, 5th, 8th as a fantasy QB the last few years even with his often erratic play. Stallworth's development should also help him out.

CB pretty much summed up the rest, although I would like to see Curtis Martin in the top fifteen.

[maddog60]

LJ Smith should not be above Wiggins.
Plummer finished ~6th in QBs last year, he's not going to finish 15th.
D-Jax is too high.

[Nfl Fan]

I hope you're right about Hass!

[bellybrother]

A few minor differences in yours and mine, but overall I like it alot.

QB Wow, QB's are deep this year. Taking a QB early is looking less appealing the more I think about it. You have Hass and Vick higher than I do and i would expect Plummer to finish higher.

RB A few switched in the top and middle but very close to mine. The bottom 3rd is just about opposite of mine.

WR I like Ward there. I have Clayton higher and Bennett out. Moose and Chambers right there.

TE Alge and McMichael Ahead of Clark. And Pollard a little higher.

And I agree with the points CB made also.

Nice list.