Onterrio Smith OR Amos Zereoue...

[Clevelander]

who would you chose and why...

both as in many drafts are 50/50 backs. one gained the starting job over the bus...does that hold and i believe he should have some good numbers this year...the other is the player to be...over bennett...will he also maintain the start and produce big.

i have to chose one in a deal and dont mind either but i want to make the right choice...im leaning toward zereoue only because hes somewhat proven and pitt like to run just as much as the pass....as to the unproven...i hate the label 'the next big player', i guess its a chance to take...

anyone elses thoughts...

[Cornbread Maxwell]

tough call

Neither are in that great of a situation. I certainly wouldnt want my RB being backed up by Bettis. And I also dont want MINs RB either - the team led the league in rushing last yr, yet a healthy bennett barely broke the top 20 rbs. Both will lose goalline carries pretty badly.

I guess go with Zereoue. flip a coin...

[Homeless]

Im with you in that I favor Zero of the two right now.

[yoda83]

assuming he doesnt have repeat performances of last night, i like zereoue, too.

[NFLknowitall]

What I would do is if my two starting RB's were good/solid non-injury type of back (ie. Not Fred Taylor or Eddie George) then I would take a chance with Onterrio. If you need the extra security then I'd go with Zereoue. I watched Onterrio in college and he is one hell of a back. Honestly, I would not be surprised if Bennett never gets his job back. Honest.