portisfan24 wrote:Ya I wouldnt want to draft 5th this year. I think I might have to go with Jamal over Deuce and Edge.
by the way, whatever happened to Mcgahee being a top 5 pick? I swear half the people on this board were in love with him like 2 months ago.
They woke up and realized he has never played a full NFL season, and had a blown out knee not that long ago, and has a medicore 40 time, on a mediocre offensive team.
That aside, I still think he's a bottom of the first round pick, higher in keeper leagues.
As to number 5 it depends on your scoring system, I dont think Manning should go below 2 in ANY league that awards 6pts to a qb for throwing a TD (this is simple to prove mathmatically), but youre still stuck with that num 5 pick.
Personally, I think Deuce is in for a rebound yr and would take him there. Though, if youre in a league that gives you points for recpeptions, you have to consider A Green. Yes I know he was a flop for what he was expected. If yout hink he TOTALLY SUCKS, which is a reasonable view point, then take D Davis -- theyre both locks for over 50 catches.
You could always take Barber, he might not put up number 5 numbers, but i dont think there is any way he finishes out of the top 10 --- and he's the ONLY one I can see you can guarentee that with - deuce, edge, DD -- they all could slip.
That aside, id still stick with deuce and his contract year