2005 Cafe Fantasy Football Mock Draft

[Mercer Boy]

Doesn't matter if you have 10 or 10000 posts; everyone has an opinion.

I'm still in the "no chance in heck Manning goes over 40 TD's" camp, which is going to be imperative in Manning being worth a top pick. All QB's score well, and since only 10-12 start, the point differences just aren't high enough to lose out on the top RB's unless you pick near the end of the 1st round. At that point, there is value in the pick as you can get a "decent" RB quickly on the way back around. Still, you're hoping that Manning blows all other QB's out of the water.

I've drafted mid/low level QB's in my entire fantasy life, and I've definitely won more games than I've lost.

[awwchrist]

I'd be in the same Manning camp if McNabb wasn't wrestling with Owens, and Culpepper wasn't missing Moss, and the KC offense wasn't a year older...etc.

Hell the only top 10 QB who's situation has gotten significantly better over last year is Delhomme.

Just sayin..where's manning's competition?

[PACKman1144]

I'd be in the same Manning camp if McNabb wasn't wrestling with Owens, and Culpepper wasn't missing Moss, and the KC offense wasn't a year older...etc.

Hell the only top 10 QB who's situation has gotten significantly better over last year is Delhomme.

Just sayin..where's manning's competition?

Exactly he's by far the best QB available, and he has so many weapons on his offense.
But don't take him early 1st round somewhere in the middle or late.

[Shader]

I think Manning is 5-8 points better than the next quarterback. I don't see Culpepper even coming close.

With all the parity among running backs 4-15, I think taking Peyton in the middle of the first is completely fine, but do what's best for your league.