Trade Committee

[Finest]

any ideas how i should go about accepting trades as a commish,ex(committee,leasgue votes) had problems with uneven trades last year.

[Vikes_Fan2823]

League votes are the best way IMO, gives everyone a chance to have their voice heard.

[dan9124]

if it was me, i'd just do what was in my best judgement. if you put it up to a league vote, some people might vote it down just because they think they'll be hurt because it'll make one or both teams better. or maybe going by fantasy points. set a limit of how much difference there can be in fantasy points earned. actually, nevermind that last one b/c if one player starts to emerge in the middle of the year, that would be a big problem b/c they wouldnt have the sufficient pts but may have the same value as an established starter.

[BrutallyHuge]

Leagues votes are we-todd-did unless you are a group of close-knit friends.

If it's a public league or some chumps you meet on the Timberlake message board, you'll get people vetoing left and right. If a trade makes a team a tiny bit stronger, it will get vetoed because people don't want another team to get better...only their own.

Best is commish veto with a good commish. We elect people to govern. Do you really want to poll the country every time a president wants to do something? Chaos. In fantasy football, the results could be even more disastrous.

[Redskins Win]

Fantasy Football isn't a democracy. You must rule with an Iron Fist. Opinions should be welcomed and weighed and then dismissed. That's why you're the Comish to determine if a trade is shady. If you have any doubts just make a post for advice and unbiased opinions on trades

[mrider]

League votes are the best way IMO, gives everyone a chance to have their voice heard.

Yeh but that diminshes the point of fantasy football because when your trying to trade you obviously want to get the most for the least. And if your in a close race and people around you dont want you to get a good player at a certain position because it will put your team over the top then they vote no/ I think commish should decide makes the most sense IMO.