Why no love for Tiki?

[BrutallyHuge]

Tiki is kinda short. Also, I can't tell Tiki and Ronday apart.

[Santana]

I don't doubt his ability to have another strong year. His problem was always fumbles, which he seemed to fix. Jabobs is the sole reason I stayed away this year.

[maddog60]

Having this dilhemma is a bit of a good thing. I would keep Westbrook because of the youth factor. Westbrook was and will likely remain a 10-15 RB. Tiki had his best year ever, and career highs aren't often repeated this late in a player's career. In redraft though, I'd want Rudi and Tiki slightly more though.

[Mookie4ever]

Why do people think that the rookie Jacobs will be more successful taking away goal line carries than Dayne was?

[Cornbread Maxwell]

What happened in 2002 then? He had as many fumbles as in 2003, yet he still had 11 TDs.

I hear what you are saying Mook - but I just dont put as much faith in that argument - there aer just too many other factors. Head coach, SoS, fumble issue may return, the fact that it seems the Giants have been trying to take the load off Tiki for a while and now they used an early pick on another RB. There just seem to be a lot of questions that arent answered by the theory he stopped fumbling so now everythings ok.

Dont get me wrong, I have him ranked pretty high - 10-13 range for RBs, so its not like I think he'll bust - I just think there are a good 10 or so RB better than him this yr.

[BronXBombers51]

Why do people think that the rookie Jacobs will be more successful taking away goal line carries than Dayne was?

Cuz Dayne sucks.

[Kensat30]

Why do people think that the rookie Jacobs will be more successful taking away goal line carries than Dayne was?

Cuz Dayne sucks.

Dayne was not a short-yardage RB despite his size. Jacobs is.