I'd go with Fred Taylor. He hasn't missed significant time in three years, and he has a much better line than the 49ers do. Barlow I think will be pressed by Frank Gore. Not that I'm saying Gore has a ton of value either, as the 49ers' line is simply horrendous, so I'm staying away from the 9er offensive players. Fred Taylor should get the majority of the carries for the Jags, and even if he doesn't get all the TDs, he should top last year's total of two. The law of averages would say that he would return to 5 or 6 at least.