I understand your point, but I don't quite agree. The lotto analogy is not quite correct in that its not one single game with the same players, but multiple games. If you were to pick the same four numbers in 16 different lotto games, wouldn't you think your odds increase? I think it is very possible to win multiple leagues with multiple different player combinations, it all depends on the draft. Like with anything, a solid foundation is key, and trust me, I won't be like others who will be scrambling around all season to shore up weaknesses. For me, the hard work is done (the draft), now its all maintenance.
Congrats with you and your fiance. I've been married for 10 years and football only gets in the way on Sunday.
btw, I'm only in two money leagues, the rest were "mocks" leading up to the money league drafts.