Top 15 running back list whats yours?

[GreenBay4Life]

1. Portis
2. Lt
3. Rickey williams
4. Marshall Faulk
5. Priest holmes
6. Shaun Alexander
7. Duece Mcallister
8. Travis Henry
9. Ahman Green
10. Edge
11. Stephen Davis
12. Jamal Lewis
13. Tikki Barber
14. Fred Taylor
15. William Green

[Guest]

1.ricky
2.lt
3.holmes
4.portis
5.alexander
6.faulk
7.deuce
8.henry
9.edge
10. ahman
11.tiki
12.davis
13.lewis
14.william green
15.fred taylor

[yoda83]

good list. but boot out Fraud and stick in garner.

[The Guru]

good list. but boot out Fraud and stick in garner.

Garner? you mean I've been hurt the entire preseason Garner.[/sarcasim]

My List:

LT
Ricky
Portis
Holmes
Faulk
Duece
Shaun A
Edge (He is creeping up on my rankings, Edge is Back!)
Henry
Green
--Big Line--
Davis
Lewis
Dillion
Freddy
Tiki
Willy Green (I know this is #16 but he belongs on this list)

[yoda83]

guru, a conversation about charlie garner, injuries and the Fraud... and you question garner?!!! where have you been the last half decade? where have you been this preseason? yes, Fraud has been at it again. how many days of the preseason has Fraud taken off already? he's just waiting for unsuspecting owners to draft him, so he can pull up limp...once again. but it's all good 'cause he actually made it through a full tour of duty last year... what a joke. to quote a jedi:

"Boot out Fraud and stick in garner".

[MCG321]

good list. but boot out Fraud and stick in garner.

Garner? you mean I've been hurt the entire preseason Garner.[/sarcasim]

Not much different than Fragile Fred...

[yoda83]

fragile fraud has missed about 23 games in the last 4 years. how many has charlie g. sat for?

[The Dude_ffc]

how can you not put Garner in the top 10? So what if he hasn't played in PRE season. LT has had like 20 combined carries in the PRE season over the last 2 seasons. It really hinges on the scoring system though. If you get points for rec.'s Garner had 92 last year. But 1800 combined yards and not in the top 15? ALso, I look at schedules...

Portis
Williams
Faulk
LT
Holmes
Deuce
Alexander
A Green
Edge
Garner
Henry
Lewis
Davis
Tiki
Dillon

[The Guru]

guru, a conversation about charlie garner, injuries and the Fraud... and you question garner?!!! where have you been the last half decade? where have you been this preseason? yes, Fraud has been at it again. how many days of the preseason has Fraud taken off already? he's just waiting for unsuspecting owners to draft him, so he can pull up limp...once again. but it's all good 'cause he actually made it through a full tour of duty last year... what a joke. to quote a jedi:

"Boot out Fraud and stick in garner".

I'm not too high on Freddy either. Both Garner and Freddy have been hurt this preseason so I'm low on both of them. The only reason I even have Freddy in the top 15 is b/c he has so much potential. Garner is not a top 15 RB; he is a bad #2 RB. He's only a #3RB this year now that he is 30.

[chinch sacs]

1. Williams
2. LT
3. Portis
4. Holmes
5. Faulk
6. Alexander
7. McAllister
8. Henry
9. James
10. A. Green
11. Barber
12. Lewis
13. FRAUD
14. Dillon
15. Garner