by Cornbread Maxwell » Fri Sep 16, 2005 11:23 am
I dont think last yr was a fluke at all - but likewise I dont think he'll be a top 10 fantasy QB either. Basically to me there are a ton of QBs in his range that could put up numbers as good or better than him this yr. The difference between the 6th best QB and the 15th best QB in fantasy could end up being roughly 30 points in standard scoring. Thats how close all these guys are.
Point is - are you THAT much more confident that Brees puts up substantially better numbrs than Hasselbeck, Plummer, Brady, Delhomme, Brooks, Pennington, Palmer, Griese, McNair, Vick, or Harrington? None of these guys are considered in the top 5 and Brees regularly gets ranked close to the top of this group. Any of them has a chance to crack the top 10 - its not like Brees has that much of an advantage over the group.
Yes, Brees could easily crack the top 10 - but the group of QBs he is being ranked in is so close, that drafting him or ranking him consistantly ahead of these other guys would have been a mistake. Many rankings had Brees in the top 10 - so I guess Im not sure what the beef is.