what in the world?!?!?!?!

[Posse]

Carolina might have been in the Super Bowl last year if he didn't get injured.

I would include him in my top 5.

[Warhawk]

I'm surprised that Marvin Harrison has already dropped out of most of your top 5s.

[maddog60]

I'm surprised that Marvin Harrison has already dropped out of most of your top 5s.

Hasn't dropped out of mine, but I'd bet on him dropping before TO, Moss, CJ, or Holt.

[petedog9]

Marvin is still a great WR but he is no longer the STUD he was a few years ago. There is just too many weapons there and the Indy offense flows better when they spread the ball around. As far as pure WR talent he is tops. Crisp route runner, smart heady player but he just doesnt get enough opportunity with Wayne, Stokeley, Edge, Clark etc getting touches as well....

I have it as

Moss
T.O.
Holt
CJ
S. Smith

[Jscupa]

steve smith as 12 yards vs the packers

12 yards

I rest my case

[J2thez929]

steve smith as 12 yards vs the packers

12 yards

I rest my case

God forbid someone has a lackluster game. I mean, what the hell was he thinking! He has gotta put up 100+ every single game...Geez!

[Jscupa]

thats what top 5 wrs do

[J2thez929]

thats what top 5 wrs do

Oh really?

2004 Randy Moss

week 13 = 4 catches, 31 yards
week 16 = 2 catches. 30 yards
week 17 = 5 catches, 66 yards

I guess that doesn't make him a top 5 WR...

[Jscupa]

he was hurt and he still avg. 41 yds a game in that stretch

please show me where he had 12 yards and was fully healthy

[J2thez929]

he was hurt and he still avg. 41 yds a game in that stretch

please show me where he had 12 yards and was fully healthy

Look, I'm not saying that Steve Smith is Randy Moss but Smith is top WR this year(barring any injuries) You gotta expect some poorer games b/c he did miss the entire 2004 season. But when it's all said and done Steve Smith should be in the upper echilon of WRs for the 2005 fantasy season