Lloyd will have the occasional big play, and the guy has about the most amazing pair of hands I've seen, but the fact remains that Battle plays the position in the WCO that Rice did, and Lloyd plays the position Taylor did. Battle has two less receptions than Lloyd thus far, and has played one less game.
Lloyd may turn out have more fantasy points b/c of touchdowns, but Battle will certainly get more "looks", which gives you more opprotunities for points.
If Rattay keeps playing like he is, it's not too likely he makes it past the 9ers bye (I actually HOPE he plays against Indy and then let Smith take over). And I, for one, would not want to rely on the arm of a rookie for my fantasy team.
my .02 cents