Blockbuster trades on the table: please provide input!!!

[Murphy's Law]

here's what I'm facing:

Trade: M. Faulk, Lamar Gordon and Steve McNair
For: Drew Bledsoe, Anthony Thomas and Issac Bruce

or trade Faulk and Gordon
for Eddie George, Marty Booker, Plaxico Buress

or trade Faulk, Gordon, McNair
for Culpepper, Steven Davis, Antonio Freeman

I'm set on dealing Faulk due to the various needs I have on my team. Which do you think is the best return?

The league scores 1 pt for 20 yds passing, 4 pts passing TD, 1 point 10 yds rush/receive, 6 pts rush/receive TD, 2 bonus pts evry 5 catches.

[Guttpuppy]

If you need a starting QB,go with the Bledsoe deal.

[JayM09]

do trade #1

[joester]

Who is on your roster.

[terpfan]

if u need a qb this is a good deal. if u have someone about as good as bledsoe i wouldnt do it.

[Murphy's Law]

If I do the Bledsoe deal my starters would be:

Bledsoe QB
Thomas and Antowain Smith at RB
Eric Moulds, Issac Bruce, Ike Hilliard at WR
Byron Chamberlin at TE
Phil Dawson at K
Giants D

Back-ups are
Couch, Jaime Martin
Thomas Jones, Moe Williams
D'Wayne Bates, Jerry Porter (weak at back-up WR)
Anthony Becht

[kashikis]

go with the first deal to upgrade your QB also you wont drop too far off pace w/ thr RB and you get bruce thrown in

[Guest]

Faulk is just getting warmed up ! Don't trade him especially w Martin coming in and the Rams looking to run and pass a lot to him. Faulk should carry the Rams and your Fantasy team too. Just because you have needs and holes on your team (like a 2nd receiver) dont't panic or give up!!

[joe_montana]

Don't do any of these trades. You aren't getting enough for Faulk. These are all steals for the other teams. Don't get desperate. Faulk will carry you.

[gavin256]

I agree montana. MARSHALL MARSHALL MARSHALL!!!! He will carry you. Especially with warner out. There gonna look to him 30-35 times a game. Hopefully, cuz i got him off waivers on one of my teams. Stupid people huh?