Punt returns maybe, but his touches are going to be limited because that offense will have a hard time moving the chains.
McNabb was very seasoned in that offense, and he was able to work the middle of the field very efficiently.
I've always liked McMahon, but he cannot make the plays that McNabb made. Without TO and McNabb, Westie becomes the center of attention. He will see 8-man fronts and he will never get a clean release in the passing game again until there is a QB that can stretch the field like McNabb.
Trade him now to an owner who thinks that McMahon can sustain Westie's production, because after this Sunday, West will be in Mewelde Moore territory...