well some of this comes from the coaching philosohpy, not the QB.
Like I said other than Brady and the soon to be retired farve, Who has won more regular season or plyoff games?
In terms of the super bowl -- yea, NE did SOME things. But taking credit for the Pass to Westbrook was "ill-advised"? I think not. The eagles had the pats dead to rights, that TD would have put them in a hole. McNabb didn't do something stupid, he executed poorly.
Yea, he has his faults, but personally -- I would only take Peyton over him for the Eagles.
The flip side to the arguemnt is "yea, he goes down in flames in the big game" -- but they had no business being in some of those big games without his efforts to get them there.
At the end of the day, some philly fans can definitely be stupid.
He finally gets a complementary receiver, and they come within three points of the super bowl. perhaps if they get a sane number one wr, they can go back.
The opening scene of the movie "Saving Private Ryan" is loosely based on games of dodgeball Brian Dawkins played in second grade.