IF McNabb's out, and Owens is in, what is McMike's Value?

[Atog]

What is Mike McMahon's value if he's starting the rest of the season for the Eagles? How would that be affected if TO somehow comes back?


(Note: I don't want someone to get me wrong here--McNabb isn't technically done for the season yet)

[Shatner8]

I would say that McMahon has very minimal fantasy value for the rest of the year. Obviously TO's return will raise his value, but for now I would take guys like Warner, Simms and Losman over him

[mattb47]

Without TO he is pretty worthless fantasy wise. He has very few weapons on that team since they lost TO....and the one weapon he has is going to be targeted by defenses to be taken away (Westbrook). Brown and Lewis better step it up BIG TIME if he is going to have any kind of success at all. If TO comes back he has quite a bit more value but still not any better than most of the QBs in the NFL.

[maddog60]

Don't forget about LJ Smith. He's improved alot, and is one of the more threatening TEs in the NFC this year. Having a reliable pass catching TE is going to be huge for a backup QB.

But I'd expect that if McMahon does well, he'll be having 1 TD, and 2 TD weeks with the Eagles relying on Gordon and Westbrook more in the redzone.

[Vixtor]

He's got little to no value. About the same as J.P. Losman or less.