josebach wrote:So you are either saying that Roethisberger and Maddox are close to the same skill level or that they are not close to the same skill level and the fact that Roethlisberger has better statistics is just a coincidence.
Either way, you lost me.
No - Im saying that you cannot look at the numbers and say which one is more "talented". If you try and draw conclusions to each players abilities from the statistics you would be guessing. People who watch them play would tell you with much more accuracy each players strengths and weaknesses - thats the entire point.