Help me choose

[gogogadget]

I had some time today and made a sig for myself. I'm not sure what to think of it. I would like to know whether or not you guys like it better or worse than my current one. I have quickly made a few variations of the sig while I have been trying to decide whether or not I want to use it. I decided to ask for your opinions to help me out.

Anyway, here are the variations I have been working on this evening.

First edition


Second


I wasn't sure about the orange striped so I did away with them and made this version


Former Sig


Thanks ahead of time for any comments

[kanezfan11]

I like the third one best and better than your current sig. The first one is pretty good also, but don't really like #2 with the orange covering.

[South Park Cows]

If you made the stripe on #1 more orange-ish then you'd have yourself a nice looking sig.

[kanezfan11]

If you made the stripe on #1 more orange-ish then you'd have yourself a nice looking sig.

That's actually what I was just thinking also, but the color probably lost some "vividness" as it was downsized.

[gogogadget]

Thanks for the comments so far, I have decided to sport the third one for now. But I am still open for more opinions. I posted my previous sig above so that others could still compare them.

[deluxe_247]

i like the first one the best, but agree with SPC that it would look better with a darker orange.

[Guttpuppy]

If you could make the tiger in the original smaller as in the new ones then I'd say it is the best... even as is I'd have to say I like it a bit better than the new ones. If I had to choose one of the new ones I'd pick the first edition.