I think a modified Bobblehead would be great for a runner up or boobie prize. Perhaps a Michael Vick/Ricky Williams/Kevin Jones or some other overhyped player would be funny.
For the champ, I think an NFL replica helmet would be awesome. Perhaps you could get a blank helmet somehow and get a customized decal that has some kind of design representing your league.
These things could be expensive, so it might be a trophy that gets passed from winner to winner each successive year. It would also be cool to write the year and champs name on it as an ongoing list.
RIDERS OF THE STORM
RB Adrian Peterson, Matt Forte, Lesean McCoy
WR Brandon Marshall, Kenny Britt
DEF Flavor of the Week
=====> Post Feedback if my Reply Helped you