Cutler, Leinart or Young

[TN_Titans_05]

I don't have the NFL Network so that is news to me. I can't see them grabbing him at #2, they would have to trade down if they wanted him.

Unless the Titans take him first

[Kensat30]

I'm just waiting for the massive Cutler hype to start up so he can jump past Vince Young on peoples' draft boards.

The massive Cutler hype has been going on for about a month and a half now man.

no, kidding... i'm sick to death of it already.

I put Young, but I meant to put Leinart, sorry fellas. Is Cutler already the consensus #1 QB or is that yet to come still. I'm not keeping up with the hype trains very closely. I did hear the little blurb about him being the next Brett Favre, although I don't know how old that is.

[TheRawDAWG]

I'm just waiting for the massive Cutler hype to start up so he can jump past Vince Young on peoples' draft boards.

The massive Cutler hype has been going on for about a month and a half now man.

no, kidding... i'm sick to death of it already.

I put Young, but I meant to put Leinart, sorry fellas. Is Cutler already the consensus #1 QB or is that yet to come still. I'm not keeping up with the hype trains very closely. I did hear the little blurb about him being the next Brett Favre, although I don't know how old that is.

He hasn't passed Leinart yet...but he's about even now. And the Jets may have changed their mind on who they will try to trade up to get. Cutler could end up the #1 pick Overall. I'm not sure I agree with that, but I also don't think Any of the QBs this year are going to be superstars. Young and Leinart are so overhyped it's not funny. Leinart has a noodle for an arm and Young will be like Vick. Good but not great. And thats his ceiling. Cutler is the only one with a shot if you ask me to do anything GREAT in this league. And even thats a LONG shot. 2 years in a row a team may be wasting the #1 pick on an overhyped QB.

[houstonherdfan]

I am not at all sold that these 3 end up where you have them. houston may trade the 1st pick. I myself think they should (but that is a different thread). So with the senario you proposed,

I think Leinart will have the #3 career. NO just has never shown much ability to coach to the abilities of their QB. Be that cause of no O-line, lack of D to keep them in the game, lack of other offensive performers, or just not able to put a game plan together that suits the abilities of their QB. At least one of these have ocurred to the NOS almost every year of their existence.

I look to Young being #2 only because of the situation above with leinart. He I think will have a decent career. If he can sit behind McNair for 2 years (doubtful) he could have a good career and move into the #1 spot here. He does have a good arm but it needs some work and will learn this once he get to the NFL. McNair is just the guy to help him.

Cutler is moving into the best position. He will have a couple years to sit behind Warner to learn the NFL and the system. Green by that time will have had enough time to address the needs at o-line and have a pretty solid team.

so my ranking is

Cutler
Young
Leinart

Present QB skills wise I would rank

Cutler
Leinart
Young

Future QB skills wise who knows depends on alot of things. flip a freakin coin.

[steelerfan513]

I am not at all sold that these 3 end up where you have them. houston may trade the 1st pick. I myself think they should (but that is a different thread). So with the senario you proposed,

I think Leinart will have the #3 career. NO just has never shown much ability to coach to the abilities of their QB. Be that cause of no O-line, lack of D to keep them in the game, lack of other offensive performers, or just not able to put a game plan together that suits the abilities of their QB. At least one of these have ocurred to the NOS almost every year of their existence.

I look to Young being #2 only because of the situation above with leinart. He I think will have a decent career. If he can sit behind McNair for 2 years (doubtful) he could have a good career and move into the #1 spot here. He does have a good arm but it needs some work and will learn this once he get to the NFL. McNair is just the guy to help him.

Cutler is moving into the best position. He will have a couple years to sit behind Warner to learn the NFL and the system. Green by that time will have had enough time to address the needs at o-line and have a pretty solid team.

so my ranking is

Cutler
Young
Leinart

Present QB skills wise I would rank

Cutler
Leinart
Young

Future QB skills wise who knows depends on alot of things. flip a freakin coin.

i do not see cutler making it anywhere near the 10th overall pick. the cards will have to trade up to even think about this. cutler will go before the top 5 picks are gone, probably to the jets.

[houstonherdfan]

I am not at all sold that these 3 end up where you have them. houston may trade the 1st pick. I myself think they should (but that is a different thread). So with the senario you proposed,

I think Leinart will have the #3 career. NO just has never shown much ability to coach to the abilities of their QB. Be that cause of no O-line, lack of D to keep them in the game, lack of other offensive performers, or just not able to put a game plan together that suits the abilities of their QB. At least one of these have ocurred to the NOS almost every year of their existence.

I look to Young being #2 only because of the situation above with leinart. He I think will have a decent career. If he can sit behind McNair for 2 years (doubtful) he could have a good career and move into the #1 spot here. He does have a good arm but it needs some work and will learn this once he get to the NFL. McNair is just the guy to help him.

Cutler is moving into the best position. He will have a couple years to sit behind Warner to learn the NFL and the system. Green by that time will have had enough time to address the needs at o-line and have a pretty solid team.

so my ranking is

Cutler
Young
Leinart

Present QB skills wise I would rank

Cutler
Leinart
Young

Future QB skills wise who knows depends on alot of things. flip a freakin coin.

i do not see cutler making it anywhere near the 10th overall pick. the cards will have to trade up to even think about this. cutler will go before the top 5 picks are gone, probably to the jets.

I don't think all 3 of these guys will go to where the original post said either. was responding to his question as stated.

[TheRawDAWG]

I am not at all sold that these 3 end up where you have them. houston may trade the 1st pick. I myself think they should (but that is a different thread). So with the senario you proposed,

I think Leinart will have the #3 career. NO just has never shown much ability to coach to the abilities of their QB. Be that cause of no O-line, lack of D to keep them in the game, lack of other offensive performers, or just not able to put a game plan together that suits the abilities of their QB. At least one of these have ocurred to the NOS almost every year of their existence.

I look to Young being #2 only because of the situation above with leinart. He I think will have a decent career. If he can sit behind McNair for 2 years (doubtful) he could have a good career and move into the #1 spot here. He does have a good arm but it needs some work and will learn this once he get to the NFL. McNair is just the guy to help him.

Cutler is moving into the best position. He will have a couple years to sit behind Warner to learn the NFL and the system. Green by that time will have had enough time to address the needs at o-line and have a pretty solid team.

so my ranking is

Cutler
Young
Leinart

Present QB skills wise I would rank

Cutler
Leinart
Young

Future QB skills wise who knows depends on alot of things. flip a freakin coin.

i do not see cutler making it anywhere near the 10th overall pick. the cards will have to trade up to even think about this. cutler will go before the top 5 picks are gone, probably to the jets.

I don't think all 3 of these guys will go to where the original post said either. was responding to his question as stated.

Guys, you have to look at the date i posted the original topic. At that time it was almost gauranteed where these 3 guys were going to end up. But now, Cutler's stock has soared and Vince Young's Rose Bowl has worn off. So I agree that right now they probvably wont end up where I had originally said.