Schaub, Atlanta and a possible Abraham deal - my thoughts

[maddog60]

great article no1! Michael Smith is one of the few analysts that regularly makes insightful and logical points in my opinion.

It's no wonder Schaub hasn't been traded if the Falcons aren't even letting him go for just a 1st rounder, but someone will probably make a run at him as an RFA next year.

[CHE]

Why doesnt the Jets trade John Arbham for Schaub , TJ Duckette and a 2nd round pick.

[steelerfan513]

if schaub is smart, he doesnt resign with them and goes somewhere where he can start. for now, it gives the falcons the flexibility to rest vick with any injury and have confidence they can still win.

[J_rob_the_ Baller]

Why doesnt the Jets trade John Arbham for Schaub , TJ Duckette and a 2nd round pick.

mainly because the falcons didnt want to part with schaub.
I think the Jets would have been all over that deal

[Kensat30]

Schaub in a BEST case scenario will be Gus Frerotte, and until you can point to something other than Michael Vick being injury prone and 1 game against a weak secondary, you lack the credibility to say that OTHER people "don't know anything about football or can't evaluate talent."

This coming from the guy that said Kyle Orton would do the same thing to NE that Schaub did. OKAY!

[mattb47]

Actually Mach, I think people like Schaub because he's got the perfect size and character traits to be a succesful QB in the league, fairly good arm strength, a natural leader, a good collegiate career, and has been given that analysis by many, many professional NFL scouts (who evaluate talent for a living, by the way).

But you had some pretty good points too... oh, wait.

which of the "many many professional NFL scouts" said he was the next Matt Hasselbeck?

seriously, you're wasting everyone's time - cite a source or stop making things up.

Actually....I find my time being wasted much more by reading your ramblings then I do reading cowboys posts.....

You have no argument against the fact that Schaub is a good build for an effective NFL QB and the argument that he has played limited amounts can go both ways. He could turn out to be a bust, yes, or he could be much better than any of us thinks....we just haven't seen enough to know either way.