Debate: The worst multi-year QB starter for an NFL team

[disgruntledjetsfan]

My vote NYG Dave Brown - his reign of terror was aweful

Still get the shivers when I think about Dave Brown.

I remember Dave Brown, he started for the Giants back when I lived in New Jersey, he was just god awful, I'm pretty positive there have been a lot better QBs who never got to start a game in the NFL than Dave Brown, who somehow started for a long time.

[TTTBone]

Here's your man:

Scott Brunner

Check out those career totals...48.9%, 29 TDs, 54 Int's
Or just check out 1983... 9 TDs, 22 Int's
Dood was brutal.

[Steve_L]

Cade McNown was pretty bad as well. Then again I don't remember him every playing for the Bears......I like to block that period of the Bears out

[skibrett15]

yeah, I don't think you can say that Joey is the worst as there are some good examples of worse here. He improved his yardage and TD:INT ratio each year from 2002 to 2004 as well as his QB rating. He was bad, but not the worst. Someone who was the worst wouldn't improve each year in those key areas.

[Dr. Duran Duran]

Ugh, the Colts in 86 and 87 had Jack Trudeau at quarterback. Brutally sad numbers, too. 14 touchdowns and 24 interceptions and he threw for less than 4,000 yards combined during that two year stretch. 2,225 the first year and 1,587 the next.

[spodog]

Steve Fuller, Chiefs.

[stomperrob]

Here's a site that came up with a mathematical formula for working it and they came up with the worst of time - Rick Mirer
http://www.pro-football-reference.com/b ... ess/?p=138

[sportsaddict]

Tony Banks.

Remember, this is the guy who thought it would be funny to name his dog "Felony." That's actually the name of his dog.

[bagobonez]

Quincy Carter. Hands down.

[kyguy78]

What about the David Klingler era in Cincy? Those were some downright miserable times.