BOTB: Metallica vs. The Smiths--Metallica Wins!

[BrutallyHuge]

The Smiths

Metallica is unbelievably overrated.

Just curious, but why overrated? If it's their current blend of music you're referring to, then yes, I agree. However, their first five albums are some of the most amazing metal recordings of the past twenty-odd years. In fact, I dare you to find anyone in the inner circle of the metal community that doesn't think "And Justice For All" is one of the most amazing records in the genre.

They are no-talent hacks that I'd rank just above Milli Vanilli in musical integrity.

[Dr. Duran Duran]

The Smiths

Metallica is unbelievably overrated.

Just curious, but why overrated? If it's their current blend of music you're referring to, then yes, I agree. However, their first five albums are some of the most amazing metal recordings of the past twenty-odd years. In fact, I dare you to find anyone in the inner circle of the metal community that doesn't think "And Justice For All" is one of the most amazing records in the genre.

They are no-talent hacks that I'd rank just above Milli Vanilli in musical integrity.

Yeah, that's a very well thought out and mature response.