Jerry Porter or Tim Brown

[Ronbo]

Porter has been hot as of late, so I'm thinking of dumping the old man in favor of the youngster. What do you think?

I also have Finnernan, Branch and S. Smith on my roster. My concerns is keeping two Raiders on the same roster. Somebody else already has Rice.

[a1doug182]

How could you even consider dumping someone that is as proven as Tim Brown? Porter is hot but you will regret the day that you drop Brown. I would pick Porter up, but would instead drop Finneran who has only had one good game and is unproven and without his #1 QB.

[terpfan]

NO WAY

[Draz]

If the NFL was Wall Street, I'd buy as much stock in Oakland as I possibly could...

That means bye bye Finneran.

Incidentally, I have both Porter and Finneran on my roster and Finneran has only had one game worth mentioning this year (Week 3 I believe) and I had him benched that week :\

[Ronbo]

Thanks guys, I'm going to keep the old guy. I actually dropped Finnernan for Pathon. I couldn't see loading up on two Raider WR's unless thier names were Brown Rice.

[Guest]

i would have picked up porter before picking up pathon, once stallworth comes back his role is diminished

[Draz]

Agreed, a healthy Stallworth makes you regret this move later when Pathon is getting only a couple looks per game. Get Porter while you still can.