How do my redraft QB/RB player rankings look?

[SkinSFan22]

QB
1.Peyton Manning
2.Carson Palmer
3.Tom Brady
4.Donovan McNabb
5.Matt Hasselbeck
6.Marc Bulger
7.Eli Manning
8.Daunte Culpepper
9.Jake Delhomme
10.Drew Bledsoe
11.Trent Green
12.Kurt Warner
13.Drew Brees
14.Michael Vick
15.Jake Plummer
16.Aaron Brooks
17.Ben Roethlisberger
18.Steve McNair
19.Byron Leftwich
20.Brett Favre
21.David Carr
22.Mark Brunell
23.Chris Simms
24.Philip Rivers
25.Brad Johnson
26.Jon Kitna
27.Charlie Frye
28.Billy Volek
29.Rex Grossman
30.Chad Pennington

RB
1.Larry Johnson
2.LaDanian Tomlinson
3.Shaun Alexander
4.Clinton Portis
5.Tiki Barber
6.Edgerrin James
7.LaMont Jordan
8.Steven Jackson
9.Ronnie Brown
10.Rudi Johnson
11.Cadillac Williams
12.Domanick Davis
13.Willis McGahee
14.Brian Westbrook
15.Julius Jones
16.Willie Parker
17.Reuben Droughns
18.Jamal Lewis
19.Kevin Jones
20.Warrick Dunn
21.Reggie Bush
22.Chester Taylor
23.Corey Dillon
24.Thomas Jones
25.DeShaun Foster
26.Tatum Bell
27.Deuce McAllister
28.Joseph Addai
29.Ahman Green
30.Frank Gore
31.Curtis Martin
32.Ron Dayne
33.Cedric Benson
34.Dominic Rhodes
35.Fred Taylor
36.Chris Brown
37.DeAngelo Williams
38.LenDale White
39.Laurence Maroney
40.Samkon Gado

[disasta]

move donovan mcnabb down 3-4 slots.
eli manning up 3-4 slots.
rudi johnson 3-4 slots up

[eaglesrule]

i think eli over mcnabb is hogwash. donovan has done it before without TO, eli is still growing, and the giants o is developing, on the other hand, the defenses he will face have all imrpoved in dvision, and their overall schedule is tougher.

[smackthefirst]

Agreed on the Eli McNabb comments. I would move CPepp down a few slots unless you're convinced he'll be back very soon. I also think Brooks, eventhough he's not a great real world QB, will end up higher than that b/c even in NO with all the TO's, he still put up respectable FF numbers.

The RB's are a lot harder this year than prior years and everyone has their own opinions. I would flip flop Edge and SJax, move Dunn up a few notches as well as Ctaylor (for now anyways), and I personally think FGore assuming he stays healthy (yes even in SF) will finish top 20 RB wise this year.

[Alkaholik]

cant really say anything about these....u need to post if this is for Dynasty or Re-draft, and if it's PPR or non-ppr...then i can give you a detailed answer

[smackthefirst]

True. Don't know about the PPR or not, but if this isn't a redraft and Tiki is at 5, well then we have problems.

[Kensat30]

What I'm seeing in your rankings and it's the same in A LOT of rankings out there.


Guys getting way too much love:
13.Willis McGahee
16.Willie Parker
17.Reuben Droughns

Guys not getting even close to enough love:
22.Chester Taylor
32.Ron Dayne
33.Cedric Benson

Oh, and another ranking I strongly disagree with:

20.Brett Favre

Favre below Byron Leftwich? Seriously?

[SkinSFan22]

sorry about clarifying the settings... Its a 12-team redraft with standard scoring.