V.Davis and K.Winslow

[kage812004]

what do u guys think of these 2, ive been targeting them in my drafts and i have a very important draft tonight and wondering whats a good round to take a chance on these guys? can they be dependable if im counting on one of them to be my starter?

[gatorman1122]

Winslow by a longshot.

Davis is still a rookie and has to compete with Eric Johnson, who's a pretty good pass catching TE. Alex Smith had only 1 passing td in his entire season.

[mrblitz]

Personally I think you can't go wrong with either. I would try to snag on of them in round 9 to be sure.

[Alkaholik]

Vernon Davis in a heart beat, The guy is an unusual monster of nature with his speed andability for his build and size.

Davis will be the goto check down guy for alex Smith, who has Antonio Bryant to throw to and most likely he will be rushed and have to throw down to his speedy and tall check down TE Davis.

There really is no one to steal catches in SF, i would want Davis as my backup any day of the week, he can burn safeties deep easily.

KWII on the other hand is coming back from injury and is playing with the same type of QB who isnt the best, but has Jurevicious, Edwards and Northcutt to steal passes from him, but i did hear they will be splitting him out at WR some, but i dont like the chances of him of a guy like Vernon Davis. 
 
I hope this helps

[andus]

There's got to be a better option than two unprovens. I'd stay away from both.

[stomperrob]

For the first 7 weeks while Edwards is out Winslow could see a lot of time at WR.

[J2thez929]

I guess I'm being a homer but I definately like Winslow here. He is finally healthy and looks physically better than ever. Edwards will be out until week 6 or 7 so Winslow will see a lot of passes his way as the TE and slot wideout. Plus, the Brown's offensive is geared towards TEs. Like i've said before, if Steve Heiden had 43 catches last year, think of what KWII can do.

[teacupwoozy]

I guess I'm being a homer but I definately like Winslow here. He is finally healthy and looks physically better than ever. Edwards will be out until week 6 or 7 so Winslow will see a lot of passes his way as the TE and slot wideout. Plus, the Brown's offensive is geared towards TEs. Like i've said before, if Steve Heiden had 43 catches last year, think of what KWII can do.

That isn't homerism thats just good thinking. Add in the fact that Frye will be looking for the saftey valve that winslow at TE will provide and there is no reason to not take a risk on a guy that essentially is plugging a wideout into the TE slot.

[MrTwo94]

Winslow easily. I'm targetting him and Ben Watson. Between the two of them, one will certainly be a top 10 TE with upside of top 3. Winslow has been developing quite a rapport with Frye. Not only have they been practicing together but have become friends. Each wants to do anything they can to make the other succeed. Winslow is back at full speed and should be ready to earn his keep for that #6 pick. The Cleveland offense as a whole stands to make huge strides this year. Droughns is tremendous value in the 3rd round. Winslow could be a steal in the 9th.

[The_Dude]

There's got to be a better option than two unprovens. I'd stay away from both.

I'm sympathetic to this comment the most.

I don't know which of these guys will bust out, if either of them. Currently, I have 11 guys ranked ahead of them in my redraft rankings, with Winslow at 12 and Davis at 13. There are plenty of better options this year than Winslow or Davis.