I also do not see anything wrong with that trade but the problem is not the trade. It is them holding the "noose" over your head if you don't agree. Now you know why I as a Commish only let a max. of 2 managers to know each other personally or be related. This is a scary thing for any Commish since they could ruin your hard work by a "mutiny" on the league. I also do not let a new manager that joins (who knew someone already in the league and "nrought them in) to be allowed ANY trades to take place until after 1 season. It has never been a problem in my league 7+ years going strong. Gotta nip that collusion in the "hiney" asap or it will fester until it destroys your league.
While football is King HOCKEY is the 2nd coming.