skinsfan wrote:How do you rank them, with or without the TE?
I say
Gabriel - 800yd, 10TD Caldwell - 1000yd, 6TD Watson - 700yd, 7TD Brown - 500yd, 3TD Graham - 250yd, 4TD Childress - 200yd, 2TD
Are you predicting that Chad Jackson doesn't even see the the field? And I would argue that Branch is quite a bit more talented than either Gabriel or Calwell and he never saw those numers as WR1.
"Napoleon is not only a provider for his family; he’s an attacker on the field." - Napoleon Harris' website bio
Wake up. Branch isn't gonna be there. And I'm just including guys who I think will make some impact fantasy-wise. Good point to whoever told me bout Childress, I had hear positive reports a couple weeks ago. I suppose then that we could switch him for Jackson.
skinsfan wrote:How do you rank them, with or without the TE?
I say
Gabriel - 800yd, 10TD Caldwell - 1000yd, 6TD Watson - 700yd, 7TD Brown - 500yd, 3TD Graham - 250yd, 4TD Childress - 200yd, 2TD
32 TDs to Brady without listing about 10 other guys he will throw to this year? Yeah, I'm not buying.
-
Evaluating your player projections, I think you have this situation mapped entirely wrong. Gabriel's numbers are incredibly inflated, as are Caldwells. Your biggest mistake is your underestimation of Troy Brown and even moreso the absence of other WRs, RBs, and TEs. Last year guys not named Branch, Givens, Watson, Graham, Troy Brown, Tim Dwight (WR1/2/3/4, TE1/2) Totalled: 1100/5
I think it goes something like this for 2006:
Troy Brown- 900/5
Ben Watson- 700/6
Doug Gabriel- 600/4
Reche Caldwell- 500/3
Kevin Faulk- 300/1
all other WRs, RBs, and TEs- 800/6
skinsfan wrote:Wake up. Branch isn't gonna be there. And I'm just including guys who I think will make some impact fantasy-wise. Good point to whoever told me bout Childress, I had hear positive reports a couple weeks ago. I suppose then that we could switch him for Jackson.
Wake up? Reread the post buddy. At this point I'm not figuring Branch into the equation. I'm simply stating that Branch is
more talented and polished at WR than either Gabriel or Caldwell. Therefore, predicting Gabriel AND Caldwell to post better numbers than Branch ever saw as the WR1 is a bit ignorant...don't you think?
"Napoleon is not only a provider for his family; he’s an attacker on the field." - Napoleon Harris' website bio
C'mon, be serious. With those numbers that puts Gabriel around top 10 WR, Caldwell top 25 and Watson top 3 TE. There is no way. Maybe cut those numbers in half.