Peyton vs. The Cafe: Week 3

[steelerfan513]

ill take Donovan over any of those guys, but Bulger is closer than the others.

[eaglesrule]

Donovan.

The eagles WILL NOT let up this week, based on what happened last week. Also, you have questionable health status of westbrook. If they get up, westbrook is going to sit, buckhalter in, and they probably go to a short passing attack.

I don't think there is another choice here actually.

[BigMusky]

The whole premise of this Poll was I debated with Matthias that Manning was not a first round pick and that I could pick guys two guys in later rounds and match them up to come close to Mannings numbers. One arguement many people claim why Manning is a first rounder is because he is never the highest scoring QB ever, not even his record breaking year. Well hindsight is 20/20 and that is not really a logical debate. So to do a test on this, I am using my two Qb's drafted and tracking them all season verses manning, at the same time Matthias started this pole to see if even with every QB at your disposal (not even close to reality) could the logical owners even keep pace with him.

Matthias whole point is Mannings consistancy out weighs VBD.

I think that if I am in the ball park with my actual roster Qb's then I will win the debate pretty easy (barring injury to Manning, obviously I took drafting injury prone guys for less value so their injuries would be something I have to deal with)
If the Cafe beats Manning, nothing proved...kind of expected result in my mind.
If Manning beats everyone then Matthias wins debate.

[Matthias]

Peyton Week 3:
219 passing yards - 8.76 pts
1 passing TD - 4pts
3 rushing yards - 0.3 pts
1 rushing TD - 6 pts
0 INTs, 0 fumbles - 0 pts
----------------------------------------
19.06 pts

Cafe (McNabb) Week 3:
296 passing yards - 11.84 pts
2 passing TDs - 8 pts
1 rushing yard - 0.1 pts
0 rushing TDs - 0 pts
0 INTs, 0 fumbles - 0 pts
----------------------------------------
19.94 pts

After week 3:
Peyton 19.06
Cafe 19.94

[skibrett15]

I hope that I don't get laughed off the board, but I kind of like Favre at Detriot.

Well i'm singin' your praises. I couldn't even start Favre and I'm a packer fan. Whatever. David Carr was serviceable.

[bellings]

I hope that I don't get laughed off the board, but I kind of like Favre at Detriot.

Well i'm singin' your praises. I couldn't even start Favre and I'm a packer fan. Whatever. David Carr was serviceable.

Gracias. I was a little

[benb18a]

Well Favre pretty much won my matchup.